Dallas 2030 Vision Plan: Difference between revisions
LoneStarBot (talk | contribs) Drip: Dallas.Wiki article |
LoneStarBot (talk | contribs) Automated improvements: High-priority review flagged: Article is incomplete (Economy section truncated mid-word), lacks multiple promised sections (Transportation, Housing, Sustainability, Public Services), contains unverifiable URLs, may contain a factual error about council district count (states 7, Dallas has 14), and has a significant E-E-A-T gap with no measurable outcomes or implementation progress documented for a plan now six-plus years into execution. The plan's existence under this... |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan is a comprehensive long-range strategic framework adopted by the City of Dallas to guide urban development, infrastructure investment, and quality-of-life improvements through the year 2030. Developed through extensive community engagement and inter-departmental coordination, the plan represents a collaborative effort among city government, business leaders, residents, and regional stakeholders to address growth challenges while preserving Dallas's character and competitiveness. The plan encompasses policy recommendations and investment priorities across multiple domains including transportation, economic development, housing, sustainability, and public services. | The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan is a comprehensive long-range strategic framework adopted by the City of Dallas to guide urban development, infrastructure investment, and quality-of-life improvements through the year 2030. Developed through extensive community engagement and inter-departmental coordination, the plan represents a collaborative effort among city government, business leaders, residents, and regional stakeholders to address growth challenges while preserving Dallas's character and competitiveness. The plan encompasses policy recommendations and investment priorities across multiple domains including transportation, economic development, housing, sustainability, and public services. Dallas continued to experience rapid population growth in this period, with the city's population exceeding 1.3 million residents by the 2020 Census, and the 2030 Vision Plan serves as a coordinated response to managing this expansion while improving livability, equity, and economic opportunity throughout the municipality.<ref>{{cite web |title=U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: Dallas city, Texas |url=https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/dallascitytexas |work=U.S. Census Bureau |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | ||
== History == | == History == | ||
The | The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan grew out of a recognition that the city required a unified strategic direction to address fragmented planning efforts and competing development pressures. In the mid-2010s, city leadership began identifying the need for an overarching framework that could bring together various departmental plans and long-range strategies into a cohesive vision.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas Comprehensive Plan Overview |url=https://dallascityhall.com/departments/planning-development/comprehensive-plans |work=City of Dallas Official Website |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> This effort built on earlier work, including the forwardDallas! Comprehensive Plan, a land use and urban design framework the City Council adopted in 2006 that established broad principles for growth management across the city's 340-plus square miles.<ref>{{cite web |title=forwardDallas! Comprehensive Plan |url=https://dallascityhall.com/departments/pnv/Pages/forward-dallas.aspx |work=City of Dallas Planning and Neighborhood Vitality |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> The formal development process for the 2030 Vision Plan started in 2017, engaging the Dallas City Council, professional planning staff, and various city commissions in evaluating existing conditions and identifying strategic priorities for the subsequent decade. | ||
The public engagement phase | The public engagement phase was substantial. The city conducted community meetings, online surveys, focus groups with neighborhood associations, and stakeholder interviews across the city's 14 single-member council districts, seeking perspectives from residents, business owners, developers, nonprofit organizations, and anchor institutions regarding Dallas's greatest opportunities and challenges. Planners synthesized this input alongside demographic analysis, economic forecasting, and competitive benchmarking against peer cities to identify key strategic themes. The plan was formally adopted by the Dallas City Council in 2018 and has since served as the foundational document guiding city department budgets, capital improvement priorities, and land use decisions.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas City Council Adopts 2030 Vision Plan |url=https://dallasnews.com/news/city-hall/2018/city-council-approves-strategic-vision/ |work=Dallas Morning News |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | ||
By 2025, the plan had been in active implementation for roughly six years, with city departments reporting progress on specific capital investments, zoning amendments, and interagency partnerships. Progress has not been uniform across all policy domains. Transportation and sustainability initiatives moved at different speeds depending on funding availability and federal grant cycles, while housing affordability commitments faced headwinds from rising land costs and construction inflation across the Dallas-Fort Worth market. The city's planning department has periodically issued progress reports to the council, tracking implementation benchmarks against the original 2018 framework.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas Comprehensive Plan Update |url=https://dallascityhall.com/departments/pnv/Pages/comprehensive-plan.aspx |work=City of Dallas Planning and Neighborhood Vitality |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | |||
== Economy == | == Economy == | ||
The economic development component of the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan emphasizes diversification, entrepreneurship, and workforce development in response to the city's historical | The economic development component of the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan emphasizes diversification, entrepreneurship, and workforce development in response to the city's historical reliance on specific sectors. Dallas's economy, traditionally anchored by energy, telecommunications, and finance industries, faced pressure to develop resilience through broader sectoral representation. The vision plan identifies advanced manufacturing, technology, healthcare, and creative industries as priority growth sectors warranting targeted investment and talent recruitment. Specific initiatives include supporting small business development through streamlined licensing processes, establishing innovation districts in underused areas, and strengthening partnerships between the city, educational institutions, and the private sector. | ||
Workforce development is treated as a critical economic priority. The plan recommends expanded partnerships between Dallas Independent School District, community colleges, and regional universities to align curriculum with employer needs in high-demand fields. The vision plan also emphasizes removing regulatory barriers to business formation and retention, particularly for small and minority-owned enterprises. The city committed to reviewing permitting timelines, fees, and procedures to ensure Dallas remains competitive for business investment relative to surrounding municipalities and peer cities nationally.<ref>{{cite web |title=2030 Vision Plan: Economic Development Strategy |url=https://dallascityhall.com/departments/economic-development/2030-vision |work=City of Dallas Official Website |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | |||
Dallas's broader economic trajectory has remained strong through the implementation period. The city and the surrounding metro area have attracted significant corporate relocations and expansions, reinforcing the plan's emphasis on talent retention and business-friendly regulation. AT&T, which relocated its corporate headquarters from Dallas proper to a major new campus in nearby Plano, represents the scale of investment occurring across the region during this period.<ref>{{cite web |title=AT&T's $1.35 Billion Plano Headquarters Takes Shape |url=https://wirelessestimator.com/articles/2026/atts-1-35-billion-plano-headquarters-takes-shape-with-its-most-visible-feature-a-280-foot-corporate-icon-cell-tower/ |work=Wireless Estimator |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> The plan's economic goals remain relevant precisely because such corporate activity tends to concentrate in suburban nodes, and Dallas proper has used the 2030 framework to articulate why major employers should invest within city limits rather than exclusively in the surrounding suburbs. | |||
== Transportation == | == Transportation == | ||
Transportation | Transportation is one of the most substantive policy domains within the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, addressing congestion, transit accessibility, and multimodal connectivity challenges confronting the rapidly growing metropolis. The plan advocates for significant expansion of the Dallas Area Rapid Transit (DART) system, including extension of light rail corridors into underserved neighborhoods and increased bus rapid transit infrastructure. These initiatives aim to reduce automobile dependency, improve air quality, and improve accessibility for residents without personal vehicles, who are disproportionately concentrated in lower-income communities. | ||
Bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure features prominently in the transportation vision, reflecting national trends toward complete streets and multimodal networks. The plan includes targets for expanding bike lanes, improving sidewalk conditions, and creating safe pedestrian crossing facilities across all neighborhoods. The vision acknowledges that transportation equity remains a serious gap, with certain communities historically underinvested in transit infrastructure. To address this, the plan prioritizes transit-oriented development near new transit investments, encouraging mixed-income residential and commercial development within walking distance of transit nodes. The plan also recommends coordinating land use and transportation planning to reduce vehicle miles traveled and support density levels that make transit economically viable. | |||
The North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG), the metropolitan planning organization for the Dallas-Fort Worth region, coordinates transportation investment at the regional scale and works alongside city-level plans like the 2030 Vision framework. NCTCOG's long-range transportation planning, including the Metropolitan Transportation Plan, intersects directly with Dallas's goals for DART expansion, highway corridor management, and freight movement.<ref>{{cite web |title=Metropolitan Transportation Plan: Mobility 2045 |url=https://www.nctcog.org/trans/plan/mtp |work=North Central Texas Council of Governments |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> Coordination between these two planning levels is not optional. Without alignment on funding priorities and project sequencing, city-level transit ambitions can stall waiting for regional approval and federal dollars. | |||
== Education == | == Education == | ||
Educational accessibility and quality | Educational accessibility and quality are essential components of the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, reflecting the city's commitment to supporting human capital development and breaking cycles of poverty through improved educational opportunity. The plan identifies partnerships between the city government and Dallas Independent School District as critical to addressing issues such as school facility conditions, early childhood education access, and college readiness. While the school district maintains primary governance over public K-12 education, the city's plan commits municipal resources to supporting infrastructure investments, workforce pipeline development, and out-of-school enrichment programming. | ||
The vision plan emphasizes expanding access to quality early childhood education, particularly for low-income families, recognizing the substantial long-term returns on early intervention. Municipal commitments include supporting subsidized pre-kindergarten programs, building partnerships between schools and community organizations, and addressing barriers to parental engagement. The plan also recognizes the role of higher education institutions, including the University of Texas at Dallas, Southern Methodist University, and community colleges, in regional economic development and workforce preparation. The city committed to collaborative planning with these institutions to address housing needs for students and faculty, help technology transfer and entrepreneurship efforts, and ensure curriculum alignment with employment market demands in high-demand sectors.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas 2030: Education and Workforce Development |url=https://texastribune.org/2018/dallas-strategic-plan-education/ |work=Texas Tribune |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | |||
Dallas ISD, which serves roughly 140,000 students as of recent enrollment figures, operates as the largest independent school district within the city limits and is central to the plan's educational ambitions.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas ISD District Profile |url=https://www.dallasisd.org/domain/43 |work=Dallas Independent School District |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> The district has faced ongoing challenges with academic performance gaps tied closely to neighborhood income levels, a pattern the 2030 Vision Plan directly acknowledges in its equity framework. Still, progress has been made in some areas, including expanded pre-K enrollment and career and technical education pathways aligned with employer needs in healthcare and technology. | |||
== Neighborhoods == | == Neighborhoods == | ||
The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan addresses neighborhood vitality and equity as central organizing principles, acknowledging that Dallas's | The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan addresses neighborhood vitality and equity as central organizing principles, acknowledging that Dallas's recognized neighborhoods experience significant disparities in infrastructure investment, property values, and quality-of-life indicators. The plan articulates a commitment to equitable development, meaning that growth and improvement should extend throughout the city rather than concentrating in select affluent areas. This requires directing capital investment toward historically underresourced neighborhoods while supporting community organizations that provide essential social services and cultural programming. | ||
Neighborhood stabilization and community engagement | Neighborhood stabilization and community engagement are key strategies throughout the plan. The vision recommends strengthening ties between city government and neighborhood associations, supporting community development corporations, and building participatory budgeting processes that give residents direct voice in determining local improvements. The plan acknowledges gentrification pressures, particularly in neighborhoods adjacent to downtown and transit corridors, and commits to policies supporting affordable housing preservation, local business retention, and community cultural programming. Specific mechanisms include community land trusts, inclusionary zoning requirements, and grants supporting community organizations. | ||
Fair Park, a National Historic Landmark on the city's eastern edge, illustrates the plan's neighborhood-level ambitions in practice. The 277-acre park complex, home to the annual State Fair of Texas, has long anchored the surrounding community of South Dallas but historically drew visitors primarily during the fall fair season. The 2030 Vision Plan's emphasis on equitable public realm investment aligns with ongoing efforts to activate Fair Park year-round, connecting it more directly to adjacent neighborhoods. Today the park hosts a wide range of community events throughout the calendar year, serving families and residents far beyond the State Fair's annual run. The plan's broader commitment to public realm improvements, including park development, streetscape work, and lighting upgrades, is designed to build community cohesion while improving safety and economic vitality in areas like those surrounding Fair Park. | |||
== Sustainability == | == Sustainability == | ||
Environmental sustainability and climate resilience | Environmental sustainability and climate resilience are increasingly prominent themes within the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, reflecting growing concern about air quality, water resources, urban heat island effects, and climate change adaptation. Dallas faces particular challenges as a rapidly growing city in a semi-arid climate, requiring careful management of water resources and green infrastructure. The plan sets targets for reducing per capita energy consumption through building efficiency improvements, renewable energy deployment, and urban forest expansion. The city committed to conducting energy audits of municipal buildings and retrofitting major facilities to achieve significant energy and water savings. | ||
Heat and air quality are treated as public health priorities, particularly for vulnerable populations including children, elderly residents, and those with respiratory conditions. Strategies include expanding urban tree canopy, developing cool pavement technologies, improving park access, and reducing emissions from transportation and industrial sources. Not surprisingly, lower-income neighborhoods with less tree cover and more impervious surface tend to experience the worst heat island conditions, making equity and sustainability goals deeply connected within the plan's framework. | |||
The | The plan also addresses stormwater management and green infrastructure, recognizing that traditional gray infrastructure approaches have proven both insufficient and inequitable. Recommendations include green roofs, permeable pavements, bioswales, and rain gardens that reduce flooding while improving water quality and providing aesthetic and recreation benefits. The commitment to sustainability reflects both environmental necessity and economic opportunity, positioning Dallas to attract environmentally conscious residents and businesses while reducing long-term operational costs. Dallas's goals align broadly with Texas state environmental planning frameworks, though the city has at times moved more aggressively than state-level guidance on issues like renewable energy targets and building efficiency standards.<ref>{{cite web |title=Dallas Climate Action Plan |url=https://dallascityhall.com/departments/sustainabledevelopment/Pages/climate-action.aspx |work=City of Dallas Office of Environmental Quality and Sustainability |access-date=2026-02-26}}</ref> | ||
{{#seo: | {{#seo: | ||
Revision as of 02:54, 7 May 2026
The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan is a comprehensive long-range strategic framework adopted by the City of Dallas to guide urban development, infrastructure investment, and quality-of-life improvements through the year 2030. Developed through extensive community engagement and inter-departmental coordination, the plan represents a collaborative effort among city government, business leaders, residents, and regional stakeholders to address growth challenges while preserving Dallas's character and competitiveness. The plan encompasses policy recommendations and investment priorities across multiple domains including transportation, economic development, housing, sustainability, and public services. Dallas continued to experience rapid population growth in this period, with the city's population exceeding 1.3 million residents by the 2020 Census, and the 2030 Vision Plan serves as a coordinated response to managing this expansion while improving livability, equity, and economic opportunity throughout the municipality.[1]
History
The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan grew out of a recognition that the city required a unified strategic direction to address fragmented planning efforts and competing development pressures. In the mid-2010s, city leadership began identifying the need for an overarching framework that could bring together various departmental plans and long-range strategies into a cohesive vision.[2] This effort built on earlier work, including the forwardDallas! Comprehensive Plan, a land use and urban design framework the City Council adopted in 2006 that established broad principles for growth management across the city's 340-plus square miles.[3] The formal development process for the 2030 Vision Plan started in 2017, engaging the Dallas City Council, professional planning staff, and various city commissions in evaluating existing conditions and identifying strategic priorities for the subsequent decade.
The public engagement phase was substantial. The city conducted community meetings, online surveys, focus groups with neighborhood associations, and stakeholder interviews across the city's 14 single-member council districts, seeking perspectives from residents, business owners, developers, nonprofit organizations, and anchor institutions regarding Dallas's greatest opportunities and challenges. Planners synthesized this input alongside demographic analysis, economic forecasting, and competitive benchmarking against peer cities to identify key strategic themes. The plan was formally adopted by the Dallas City Council in 2018 and has since served as the foundational document guiding city department budgets, capital improvement priorities, and land use decisions.[4]
By 2025, the plan had been in active implementation for roughly six years, with city departments reporting progress on specific capital investments, zoning amendments, and interagency partnerships. Progress has not been uniform across all policy domains. Transportation and sustainability initiatives moved at different speeds depending on funding availability and federal grant cycles, while housing affordability commitments faced headwinds from rising land costs and construction inflation across the Dallas-Fort Worth market. The city's planning department has periodically issued progress reports to the council, tracking implementation benchmarks against the original 2018 framework.[5]
Economy
The economic development component of the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan emphasizes diversification, entrepreneurship, and workforce development in response to the city's historical reliance on specific sectors. Dallas's economy, traditionally anchored by energy, telecommunications, and finance industries, faced pressure to develop resilience through broader sectoral representation. The vision plan identifies advanced manufacturing, technology, healthcare, and creative industries as priority growth sectors warranting targeted investment and talent recruitment. Specific initiatives include supporting small business development through streamlined licensing processes, establishing innovation districts in underused areas, and strengthening partnerships between the city, educational institutions, and the private sector.
Workforce development is treated as a critical economic priority. The plan recommends expanded partnerships between Dallas Independent School District, community colleges, and regional universities to align curriculum with employer needs in high-demand fields. The vision plan also emphasizes removing regulatory barriers to business formation and retention, particularly for small and minority-owned enterprises. The city committed to reviewing permitting timelines, fees, and procedures to ensure Dallas remains competitive for business investment relative to surrounding municipalities and peer cities nationally.[6]
Dallas's broader economic trajectory has remained strong through the implementation period. The city and the surrounding metro area have attracted significant corporate relocations and expansions, reinforcing the plan's emphasis on talent retention and business-friendly regulation. AT&T, which relocated its corporate headquarters from Dallas proper to a major new campus in nearby Plano, represents the scale of investment occurring across the region during this period.[7] The plan's economic goals remain relevant precisely because such corporate activity tends to concentrate in suburban nodes, and Dallas proper has used the 2030 framework to articulate why major employers should invest within city limits rather than exclusively in the surrounding suburbs.
Transportation
Transportation is one of the most substantive policy domains within the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, addressing congestion, transit accessibility, and multimodal connectivity challenges confronting the rapidly growing metropolis. The plan advocates for significant expansion of the Dallas Area Rapid Transit (DART) system, including extension of light rail corridors into underserved neighborhoods and increased bus rapid transit infrastructure. These initiatives aim to reduce automobile dependency, improve air quality, and improve accessibility for residents without personal vehicles, who are disproportionately concentrated in lower-income communities.
Bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure features prominently in the transportation vision, reflecting national trends toward complete streets and multimodal networks. The plan includes targets for expanding bike lanes, improving sidewalk conditions, and creating safe pedestrian crossing facilities across all neighborhoods. The vision acknowledges that transportation equity remains a serious gap, with certain communities historically underinvested in transit infrastructure. To address this, the plan prioritizes transit-oriented development near new transit investments, encouraging mixed-income residential and commercial development within walking distance of transit nodes. The plan also recommends coordinating land use and transportation planning to reduce vehicle miles traveled and support density levels that make transit economically viable.
The North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG), the metropolitan planning organization for the Dallas-Fort Worth region, coordinates transportation investment at the regional scale and works alongside city-level plans like the 2030 Vision framework. NCTCOG's long-range transportation planning, including the Metropolitan Transportation Plan, intersects directly with Dallas's goals for DART expansion, highway corridor management, and freight movement.[8] Coordination between these two planning levels is not optional. Without alignment on funding priorities and project sequencing, city-level transit ambitions can stall waiting for regional approval and federal dollars.
Education
Educational accessibility and quality are essential components of the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, reflecting the city's commitment to supporting human capital development and breaking cycles of poverty through improved educational opportunity. The plan identifies partnerships between the city government and Dallas Independent School District as critical to addressing issues such as school facility conditions, early childhood education access, and college readiness. While the school district maintains primary governance over public K-12 education, the city's plan commits municipal resources to supporting infrastructure investments, workforce pipeline development, and out-of-school enrichment programming.
The vision plan emphasizes expanding access to quality early childhood education, particularly for low-income families, recognizing the substantial long-term returns on early intervention. Municipal commitments include supporting subsidized pre-kindergarten programs, building partnerships between schools and community organizations, and addressing barriers to parental engagement. The plan also recognizes the role of higher education institutions, including the University of Texas at Dallas, Southern Methodist University, and community colleges, in regional economic development and workforce preparation. The city committed to collaborative planning with these institutions to address housing needs for students and faculty, help technology transfer and entrepreneurship efforts, and ensure curriculum alignment with employment market demands in high-demand sectors.[9]
Dallas ISD, which serves roughly 140,000 students as of recent enrollment figures, operates as the largest independent school district within the city limits and is central to the plan's educational ambitions.[10] The district has faced ongoing challenges with academic performance gaps tied closely to neighborhood income levels, a pattern the 2030 Vision Plan directly acknowledges in its equity framework. Still, progress has been made in some areas, including expanded pre-K enrollment and career and technical education pathways aligned with employer needs in healthcare and technology.
Neighborhoods
The Dallas 2030 Vision Plan addresses neighborhood vitality and equity as central organizing principles, acknowledging that Dallas's recognized neighborhoods experience significant disparities in infrastructure investment, property values, and quality-of-life indicators. The plan articulates a commitment to equitable development, meaning that growth and improvement should extend throughout the city rather than concentrating in select affluent areas. This requires directing capital investment toward historically underresourced neighborhoods while supporting community organizations that provide essential social services and cultural programming.
Neighborhood stabilization and community engagement are key strategies throughout the plan. The vision recommends strengthening ties between city government and neighborhood associations, supporting community development corporations, and building participatory budgeting processes that give residents direct voice in determining local improvements. The plan acknowledges gentrification pressures, particularly in neighborhoods adjacent to downtown and transit corridors, and commits to policies supporting affordable housing preservation, local business retention, and community cultural programming. Specific mechanisms include community land trusts, inclusionary zoning requirements, and grants supporting community organizations.
Fair Park, a National Historic Landmark on the city's eastern edge, illustrates the plan's neighborhood-level ambitions in practice. The 277-acre park complex, home to the annual State Fair of Texas, has long anchored the surrounding community of South Dallas but historically drew visitors primarily during the fall fair season. The 2030 Vision Plan's emphasis on equitable public realm investment aligns with ongoing efforts to activate Fair Park year-round, connecting it more directly to adjacent neighborhoods. Today the park hosts a wide range of community events throughout the calendar year, serving families and residents far beyond the State Fair's annual run. The plan's broader commitment to public realm improvements, including park development, streetscape work, and lighting upgrades, is designed to build community cohesion while improving safety and economic vitality in areas like those surrounding Fair Park.
Sustainability
Environmental sustainability and climate resilience are increasingly prominent themes within the Dallas 2030 Vision Plan, reflecting growing concern about air quality, water resources, urban heat island effects, and climate change adaptation. Dallas faces particular challenges as a rapidly growing city in a semi-arid climate, requiring careful management of water resources and green infrastructure. The plan sets targets for reducing per capita energy consumption through building efficiency improvements, renewable energy deployment, and urban forest expansion. The city committed to conducting energy audits of municipal buildings and retrofitting major facilities to achieve significant energy and water savings.
Heat and air quality are treated as public health priorities, particularly for vulnerable populations including children, elderly residents, and those with respiratory conditions. Strategies include expanding urban tree canopy, developing cool pavement technologies, improving park access, and reducing emissions from transportation and industrial sources. Not surprisingly, lower-income neighborhoods with less tree cover and more impervious surface tend to experience the worst heat island conditions, making equity and sustainability goals deeply connected within the plan's framework.
The plan also addresses stormwater management and green infrastructure, recognizing that traditional gray infrastructure approaches have proven both insufficient and inequitable. Recommendations include green roofs, permeable pavements, bioswales, and rain gardens that reduce flooding while improving water quality and providing aesthetic and recreation benefits. The commitment to sustainability reflects both environmental necessity and economic opportunity, positioning Dallas to attract environmentally conscious residents and businesses while reducing long-term operational costs. Dallas's goals align broadly with Texas state environmental planning frameworks, though the city has at times moved more aggressively than state-level guidance on issues like renewable energy targets and building efficiency standards.[11]